Features Partner Sites Information LinkXpress hp
Sign In
Advertise with Us
PURITAN MEDICAL

Download Mobile App




Significant Disparities Found between Liquid Biopsy Providers

By LabMedica International staff writers
Posted on 26 Dec 2017
Liquid biopsy is a new and noninvasive alternative to tumor tissue sequencing, and it is intended to specifically detect and sequence tumor DNA circulating in patients' blood. More...
The results are used to help guide doctors to tailor the best treatment for patients at each point of their disease.

Patients may respond differently to cancer drugs depending on what kinds of gene mutations they have in their tumors. Oncologists use the results of a liquid biopsy to see if a patient is responding to treatment and to monitor tumors to see if they are progressing and may require a new or extra therapy. They may also use the results to select patients for clinical trials, if a specific mutation is found in their tumor's DNA.

Medical scientists at Johns Hopkins Medicine (Baltimore, MD, USA) collected blood samples from 40 metastatic prostate cancer patients from January 2007 and July 2017. The samples were shipped to two laboratories that were licensed by Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments, known as CLIA, and accredited by the College of American Pathologists, and report having high sensitivity (in this case, the ability to correctly identify mutations when they occur) and high specificity (the ability to correctly report as negative when those mutations are not present).

The two liquid biopsy panels compared were the Guardant360, which sequenced at least part of the coding sequences of 73 genes, and the PlasmaSELECT panel, which sequenced coding segments of 64 genes. The two companies differ in which genes, and regions within each gene, are covered. Just 25 of the 40 patients in the study had at least one genetic mutation reported within the overlapping genetic sequences covered by both companies.

The team found that even when the companies were analyzing DNA from the same blood drawn, their results rarely matched each other. When comparing results within the overlapping genetic sequences, the results from both companies completely matched for all the mutations reported in only 3/40 patients (7.5%) of cases. In 6/ 40of the patients (15%), both companies' results matched for at least one of the reported mutations. In 16/40 (40%) of the patients, no mutations reported that were potentially covered by both panels were detected by both companies.

Each commercial test costs about USD 4,000, and patients usually only have their samples sent to one laboratory for testing. Gonzalo Torga, MD, a postdoctoral research fellow and co-author of the study said, “Liquid biopsy is a promising technology, with an exceptional potential to impact our ability to treat patients, but it is a new technology that may need more time and experience to improve. We cannot tell from these studies which laboratory's panel is better, but we can say that certification for these laboratories must improve.” The authors want to make sure oncologists are aware of the inconsistencies so that they do not blindly trust liquid biopsy results. The study was published on December 14, 2017, in JAMA Oncology.

Related Links:
Johns Hopkins Medicine


Gold Member
Troponin T QC
Troponin T Quality Control
Serological Pipet Controller
PIPETBOY GENIUS
New
Silver Member
Fibrinolysis Assay
HemosIL Fibrinolysis Assay Panel
New
Staining System
RAL DIFF-QUIK
Read the full article by registering today, it's FREE! It's Free!
Register now for FREE to LabMedica.com and get access to news and events that shape the world of Clinical Laboratory Medicine.
  • Free digital version edition of LabMedica International sent by email on regular basis
  • Free print version of LabMedica International magazine (available only outside USA and Canada).
  • Free and unlimited access to back issues of LabMedica International in digital format
  • Free LabMedica International Newsletter sent every week containing the latest news
  • Free breaking news sent via email
  • Free access to Events Calendar
  • Free access to LinkXpress new product services
  • REGISTRATION IS FREE AND EASY!
Click here to Register








DIASOURCE (A Biovendor Company)

Channels

Hematology

view channel
Image: CitoCBC is the world first cartridge-based CBC to be granted CLIA Waived status by FDA (Photo courtesy of CytoChip)

Disposable Cartridge-Based Test Delivers Rapid and Accurate CBC Results

Complete Blood Count (CBC) is one of the most commonly ordered lab tests, crucial for diagnosing diseases, monitoring therapies, and conducting routine health screenings. However, more than 90% of physician... Read more

Immunology

view channel
Image: A simple blood test could replace surgical biopsies for early detecion of heart transplant rejection (Photo courtesy of Shutterstock)

Blood Test Detects Organ Rejection in Heart Transplant Patients

Following a heart transplant, patients are required to undergo surgical biopsies so that physicians can assess the possibility of organ rejection. Rejection happens when the recipient’s immune system identifies... Read more
Copyright © 2000-2025 Globetech Media. All rights reserved.