We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience. This includes personalizing content and advertising. To learn more, click here. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies. Cookie Policy.

Features Partner Sites Information LinkXpress hp
Sign In
Advertise with Us

Download Mobile App

Fecal Immunochemical Test a Less Expensive Alternative for Colorectal Cancer Screening

By LabMedica International staff writers
Posted on 18 Oct 2022
Print article
Image: FIT has been found to detect early-stage cancer at one-fifth the cost (Photo courtesy of Allegheny Health)
Image: FIT has been found to detect early-stage cancer at one-fifth the cost (Photo courtesy of Allegheny Health)

Guidelines issued by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) suggest a fecal immunochemical test (FIT) can be used as the primary noninvasive screening modality for early-stage colorectal cancer, although a significant proportion of patients still receive a more expensive alternative test called Cologuard. Commercially available noninvasive screening tests for colorectal cancer - a FIT and the multi-target stool DNA test (mt-sDNA; or Cologuard) - are equally effective for screening patients with early-stage colorectal cancer. Data used for national screening guidelines has shown no difference between the two tests at detecting adenoma versus colorectal malignancy. However, a new study has revealed that a FIT costs about one-fifth of the multi-target DNA test. These results align with previous studies out of Japan and the Netherlands examining FIT as an appropriate screening modality that is more cost effective than other types of noninvasive colorectal screening tests.

In the study, researchers at Allegheny Health Network (Pittsburgh, PA, USA) looked at 117,519 people in the Highmark claims database who underwent colorectal screening in 2019. Highmark is a Blue Cross Blue Shield Association insurer in four Mid-Atlantic states. From that group, the researchers identified 91,297 people who had noninvasive screening with either the fecal immunochemical test (FIT, n=45,487) or the DNA test (mt-sDNA, n=46,110) instead of having a routine colonoscopy. The findings revealed that among the study population that underwent colorectal screening, 45,487 (38.7%) had one of two commercially available FIT tests and 46,110 (39.2%) had the mt-sDNA test. Patients who were screened with either test presented with early disease, staged from 0 to II, at similar rates: 59.5% for FIT and 63.2% for mt-sDNA test (p=0.77).

Patients within the Allegheny Health Network Oncology Registry diagnosed with colorectal cancer were matched to their claims data to determine distribution of cancer stage. If the noninvasive test indicated signs of early disease, patients were then referred for additional testing to confirm the findings. The total annual costs for the tests were USD 6.47 million - USD 1.1 million for a FIT, or about USD 24 per test, and USD 5.6 million for mt-sDNA, or about USD 121 per test. Costs were calculated using Medicare reimbursement rates. The researchers determined that transitioning all noninvasive colorectal cancer screening to FIT would result in a USD 3.9 million savings annually in the study population. What makes this study unique is the methodology used to analyze the claims data. The researchers analyzed outcomes in the local health registry and then applied those outcomes to the claims database. The cost of a screening colonoscopy in the database the researchers used was USD 635.

"Despite national guidelines suggesting that FIT be used as the primary noninvasive screening modality, we found that on review of our insurer's claims data, a significant proportion of patients still receive a more expensive alternative test. There is substantial cost savings not only to our patients but to our health system with promoting appropriate use of noninvasive testing," said Pavan K. Rao, MD, a general surgery resident at Allegheny Health Network. "There was no difference in the clinical stage at the time of diagnosis between the two tests, which again demonstrates the clinical equipoise maintained by switching to FIT."

"It's not just the cost of the mt-sDNA test kit or the cost of the FIT kit multiplied by the number of members in the healthcare system," said study coauthor Casey J. Allen, MD, a surgical oncologist at Allegheny Health Network. "It's the full downstream costs depending on the rates of false-positive and false-negative tests and how much it costs to obtain a colonoscopy when that occurs."

Related Links:
Allegheny Health Network 

Platinum Member
Flu SARS-CoV-2 Combo Test
OSOM® Flu SARS-CoV-2 Combo Test
Magnetic Bead Separation Modules
Anti-Cyclic Citrullinated Peptide Test
GPP-100 Anti-CCP Kit
Gold Member
Liquid Ready-To-Use Lp(a) Reagent
Lipoprotein (a) Reagent

Print article


Clinical Chemistry

view channel
Image: PhD student and first author Tarek Eissa has analyzed thousands of molecular fingerprints (Photo courtesy of Thorsten Naeser / MPQ / Attoworld)

Screening Tool Detects Multiple Health Conditions from Single Blood Drop

Infrared spectroscopy, a method using infrared light to study the molecular composition of substances, has been a foundational tool in chemistry for decades, functioning similarly to a molecular fingerprinting... Read more


view channel
Image: The Truvian diagnostic platform combines clinical chemistry, immunoassay and hematology testing in a single run (Photo courtesy of Truvian Health)

Automated Benchtop System to Bring Blood Testing To Anyone, Anywhere

Almost all medical decisions are dependent upon laboratory test results, which are essential for disease prevention and the management of chronic illnesses. However, routine blood testing remains limited worldwide.... Read more


view channel
Image: The Simplexa C. auris direct kit is a real-time polymerase chain reaction assay run on the LIAISON MDX instrument (Photo courtesy of Diasorin)

Novel Molecular Test to Help Prevent and Control Multi Drug-Resistant Fungal Pathogen in Healthcare Settings

Candida auris (C. auris) is a rapidly emerging multi drug-resistant fungal pathogen that is commonly found in healthcare environments, where it presents a challenge due to its ability to asymptomatically... Read more


view channel
Image: The tool can improve precision oncology by accurately predicting molecular subtypes and therapy responses (Photo courtesy of Shutterstock)

Computational Tool Integrates Transcriptomic Data for Improved Breast Cancer Diagnosis and Treatment

Breast cancer is the most commonly diagnosed cancer globally, presenting in various subtypes that require precise identification for effective, personalized treatment. Traditionally, cancer subtyping has... Read more


view channel
Image: Beckman Coulter will utilize the ALZpath pTau217 antibody to detect key biomarker for Alzheimer\'s disease on its DxI 9000 immunoassay analyzer (Photo courtesy of Beckman Coulter)

Beckman Coulter Licenses Alzpath's Proprietary P-tau 217 Antibody to Develop Alzheimer's Blood Test

Cognitive assessments have traditionally been the primary method for diagnosing Alzheimer’s disease, but this approach has its limitations as symptoms become apparent only after significant brain changes... Read more
Copyright © 2000-2024 Globetech Media. All rights reserved.