Direct Sequencing Measures Mutation Rate in Humans

The team sequenced the same piece of DNA--10,000,000 or so letters (nucleotides) from the Y chromosome--from two men separated by 13 generations, and counted the number of differences. Among all these nucleotides, they found only four mutations.

In 1935, one of the founders of modern genetics, J. B. S. Haldane, studied men in London (UK) with the blood disease hemophilia and estimated that there would be one in 50,000 incidence of mutations causing hemophilia in the gene affected--the equivalent of a mutation rate of possibly one in 25 million nucleotides across the genome. Others have measured rates at a few additional specific genes or compared DNA from humans and chimpanzees to produce general estimates of the mutation rate expressed more directly in nucleotides of DNA.

Extraordinarily, the new research, published in the August 27, 2009, issue of the journal Current Biology, revealed that these early estimates were correct--in total, humans all carry 100-200 new mutations in their DNA. This is equivalent to one mutation in each 15-30 million nucleotides. Fortunately, most of these are harmless and have no apparent effect on one's health or appearance. "The amount of data we generated would have been unimaginable just a few years ago,” said Dr. Yali Xue, from the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute (Cambridge, UK), and one of the project's leaders. "But finding this tiny number of mutations was more difficult than finding an ant's egg in the emperor's rice store.”

Team member Qiuju Wang recruited a family from China who had lived in the same village for centuries. The team studied two distant male-line relatives--separated by thirteen generations--whose common ancestor lived 200 years ago. To establish the rate of mutation, the team examined an area of the Y chromosome. The Y chromosome is unique in that, apart from rare mutations, it is passed unchanged from father to son, so mutations accumulate slowly over the generations. Despite many generations of separation, researchers discovered only 12 differences among all the DNA letters examined. The two Y-chromosomes were still identical at 10,149,073 of the 10,149,085 letters examined. Of the 12 differences, eight had arisen in the cell lines used for the work. Only four were true mutations that had occurred naturally through the generations.
Scientists have known for a long time that mutations occur occasionally in each human being, but have had to guess precisely how often. Now, because advances in the technology for reading DNA, this new research has been possible, according to the investigators.

Understanding mutation rates is key to many aspects of human evolution and medical research: mutation is the ultimate source of all genetic variation and provides a molecular clock for measuring evolutionary timescales. Mutations can also lead directly to diseases such as cancer. With better measurements of mutation rates, scientists could improve the calibration of the evolutionary clock, or test ways to reduce mutations, for example.

Even with the latest DNA sequencing technology, the researchers had to design a special strategy to search for the vanishingly rare mutations. They used next-generation sequencing to establish the order of letters on the two Y-chromosomes and then compared these to the Y chromosome reference sequence.

Having identified 23 candidate single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs)--or single letter changes in the DNA--the investigators amplified the regions containing these candidates and checked the sequences using the standard Sanger method. Four naturally occurring mutations were confirmed. Knowing this number of mutations, the length of the area that they had searched, and the number of generations separating the individuals, the team was able to calculate the rate of mutation.

"These four mutations gave us the exact mutation rate--one in 30 million nucleotides each generation--that we had expected,” stated the study's coordinator, Chris Tyler-Smith, also from The Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute. "This was reassuring because the methods we used--harnessing next-generation sequencing technology--had not previously been tested for this kind of research. New mutations are responsible for an array of genetic diseases. The ability to reliably measure rates of DNA mutation means we can begin to ask how mutation rates vary between different regions of the genome and perhaps also between different individuals.”

Participating Centers involved in the project include: The Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute (Hinxton, Cambridgeshire, UK); Chinese People's Liberation Army General Hospital (Beijing, China); and Beijing Genomics Institute at Shenzhen (China).

Related Links:
Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute